What do reviews say about fibers?

It uses extension-like fibers applied at the lash root, per WWD.

What do reviews say about waterproof?

This is the washable version; a waterproof one exists.

What do reviews say about ulta?

2,443 of 3,504 Ulta ratings are 5 stars.

Beauty & Skincare · Eye makeup · 3,504 reviews · 2 sources

Maybelline Falsies Surreal Extensions Mascara

Best for: false-lash length from a drugstore tubeMid-range

A fiber mascara that fakes lash extensions, adding striking length and lift while staying light, at a drugstore price.

Tracking since Sep 2026

Buy if

You want dramatic length
You like a light, buildable formula

Skip if

You want clump-free natural lashes
You have very sensitive eyes

How it scores

Efficacy9.0

Texture8.5

Price

$12.99

You pay for: Regular price

Reviewed Sep 2026 · 0 new reviews since · score unchanged

What people love

Most mentioned by reviewers

LengthEye-popping lengthening

BuildableLayers without heaviness

Curl holdKeeps lashes lifted

What people complain about

Most mentioned by reviewers

Just okaySome give it 3 stars

DislikedSome give it 2 stars

Reviewers disagree on

Extension-like dramaNot for a natural look

Alternatives

Ask about this product

Sources

Ulta
WWD
Reviewed Sep 2026

AI summary of public reviews, not a recommendation.