What do reviews say about clump?

The editor found the comb wand kept lashes separate; 1 of 8 recent Target buyers still saw clumps.

What do reviews say about remove?

The washable formula came off with micellar water for the editor; Target users rate removal lowest of 5 traits.

What do reviews say about smudge?

Most buyers report all-day wear, but a few see marks under the eyes when they sweat.

Beauty & Skincare · Eye makeup · 21,991 reviews · 3 sources

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

Best for: natural, longer lashesPremium

A cheap lengthening mascara that editors and shoppers love, with a flexible wand that separates lashes. Some buyers find it smudges or clumps.

Tracking since Sep 2026

Buy if

You want length with a natural look
You want a cheap everyday mascara

Skip if

You want big, dramatic volume
Your lower lids tend to smudge

How it scores

Efficacy9.0

Time to results9.0

Value9.0

Texture8.0

Price

$13.99

You pay for: Brand list price; often discounted

Reviewed Sep 2026 · 0 new reviews since · score unchanged

What people love

Most mentioned by reviewers

Long, lifted lashesAdds visible length

Clump-free wandFlexible comb coats each lash

Low priceOften sold below list price

What people complain about

Most mentioned by reviewers

Can smudge with sweatMarks under the eyes

Clumps for someLayers can stick together

Rated 3★ or lowerAbout 1 in 9 buyers

Reviewers disagree on

Easy to remove for manyOthers find it hard to take off

Alternatives

Same price · $13.99

Ask about this product

Sources

AI summary of public reviews, not a recommendation.